Defining Due Process

-
When it comes to terminating employees, one of the things you have to be careful about is ensuring due process.

What is Due Process?

 According to trusty, ol' Wikipedia, "Due process is the legal requirement that the state must respect all

legal rights that are owed to a person. Due process balances the power of law of the land and protects the individual person from it. When a government harms a person without following the exact course of the law, this constitutes a due process violation, which offends the rule of law."

In layman's terms, due process is the assurance or protection that there is some amount of legal process that protects any individual from some action that may be taken by the state. In corporate parlance, due process refers to the protection afforded employees, assuring them of a legal process for actions that may be taken by the employer.

Due Process and the Philippine Labor Code

 When it comes to disciplinary actions, the Labor Code requires adherence to two types of due process - substantive due process and procedural due process.

Procedural Due Process generally means that the twin-notice rule has been followed. This is done by serving a Notice of Explanation first before handing down the Notice of Decision (thus, twin notice). Keep in mind though that the respondent has to be given enough time to answer the Notice of Explanation. In the case of King of Kings Transport vs. Santiago Mamac, the Supreme Court has already established ample time to be "...a period of at least five (5) calendar days from receipt of the notice to give the employees an opportunity to study the accusation against them, consult a union official or lawyer, gather data and evidence, and decide on the defenses they will raise against the complaint".

On the other hand, Substantive Due Process, from the name itself, focuses on the substance of the case. Is there a valid reason for the disciplinary action? If there is one, is the penalty commensurate to the gravity of the offence? One of the things that you have to remember is that the burden of proof lies on the employer. This was made clear in the case of Agusan Del Norte Electric Cooperative, Inc., et al. v. Cagampang, et al.

Ensuring Due Process

In order to adhere to due process you have to keep in mind the following:
  1. Ensure that you have a well-thought Code of Conduct in place. We did two blog posts on how to do an employee handbook as well as the Code of Conduct. One of the key aspects should be a progressive disciplinary action. This is in line with the intent of any Code of Conduct - to correct employee behavior.
  2. Everyone should be familiar with your Code of Conduct. When it comes to this area, it is better to overcommunicate. Do regular refresher courses so that the employees are familiar with the process and the penalties. Managers and Leads should know the proper process of handling a disciplinary action.
  3. Your Notice to Explain (NTE) should contain all the specific details of the incident and the report raised against him. Who filed the report is not important. It's the date, time, place, etc. that is more important so make sure you have clearly indicated those. Mention also what part of the Code of Conduct was violated. It is also worth indicating if this was an initial violation or a second, third, etc. violation. This will give your employee an idea of what the penalty might be if he is proven guilty.
  4. Always close off an NTE with an NOD. Never leave an NTE open as you can use this as basis for future disciplinary action in case the employee repeats the behavior. Remember - twin-notice rule. This will also protect your company in cases of termination due to job abandonment, and allows you to officially tag an employee as separated.
  5. Documentation is important. Whether it is a simple change in job grade or a log of any coaching, a documentation of such should be made. When it comes to labor cases, it's all about what you can prove in your position paper.
  6. Ask a labor lawyer, not a corporate lawyer. While both have knowledge of the different laws of the land, a labor lawyer would be able to provide a more meaningful context as this is their specialty.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Quirky Relationship of Numbers and Retention

-
Image
An inside joke among many HR practitioners is that, they became HR to avoid numbers. Alas! HR is, at times, all about the numbers. Well, not necessarily arithmetic or algebra, but DATA. The Importance of Data Let me make this clear - gone are the days when HR choices were only based on gut-feel or stories from generations before us. A data-driven method is necessary in today's HR world, and for good reason. By using analytics, HR professionals can learn a lot about how employees behave, how engaged they are, and how happy they are with their jobs generally. When talking about retention, data is the key that shows patterns, finds trends, and helps make smart decisions. Understanding Data Analytics Data analytics exists at several levels, each of which is critical to corporate effectiveness. At its most basic is descriptive analytics , which involves summarizing and presenting data in order to provide a clear snapshot of current trends. Exploring this data aids in identifying pattern...
Read more

Monthly Paid vs Daily Paid - I'm Confused!

-
Image
Believe it or not, one of the most confusing part of payroll processing is determining the difference between monthly paid and daily paid employees. If it is your first time to process payroll, then the following might be useful to you. What does "Monthly Paid" Mean? First thing's first. Monthly paid  is different from Monthly Rate.  An employee can have a monthly rate of Php 15,000.00 but still be considered as daily paid. In the same manner, a person with a daily rate of Php 537.00 can be a monthly-paid employee. According to the 2018 Edition of the Handbook on Workers' Statutory Monetary Benefits, Monthly-paid employees are those that use "365" as the factor for determining the daily rate or the monthly rate. This means that the person is paid for every single day of the year, including rest days and special non-working holidays regardless whether the latter two are worked or un-worked. Let's say a monthly-paid employee is earning Php 25,000....
Read more

What You Need to Know About Termination of Employment

-
Image
While most see termination of employment as a negative thing, that is not always the case. In truth, termination of employment can be classified into two types - voluntary and involuntary. Voluntary and Involuntary Termination Termination is simply the process of ending one's employment in an organization. A voluntary termination is more commonly known as resignation. It is initiated by the employee by submitting a resignation letter to his/ her immediate head. Based on the Philippine Labor Code, a resigning employee has to render at least 30 days' notice prior to his/ her intended last day of work. Absent of such notice, the Company may hold the employee liable for any damages that they may suffer. Do note that, in the case of resignation with 30 days' notification, the employer may not reject it or have it ignored; otherwise, this will now become involuntary servitude. The most that the employer can do is request for an extension of the employee's last day. Now...
Read more